Ask Amma

Seven Fallacies about Menstruation and Culture

In Call to Action on 3 April 2014 at 11:15 am

Several people have forwarded to me an article, written by an educator, connecting “ancient wisdom” to the practice of menstrual taboo, and pitying the misguided women who expect modern ideas of gender and feminism to empower them.  After cataloguing popular justifications for menstrual untouchability and suggesting that they come from a time when women enjoyed respect, indeed worship, in contrast to the present context of crimes against women, the author concludes that menstrual taboo is a matter of “personal choice.”

I don’t know whether to laugh or cry.  Would those who condone menstrual untouchability extend their reasoning to untouchability that is not limited to women?  Is it also a personal choice for us to connect to the “ancient wisdom” through the practice of untouchability and caste segregation?  With more than enough relatives who would be all too happy to think so, I take this as a wake-up call to me to get back up on my bandwagon and speak for the integrity of a woman’s body, the dignity of menstruation and for a world where girls and women are free and confident in our bodies.

Ugo Omleto Giannini, "Woman with Flower." Source: Wood Turtle "Menstruation in Islam"

Ugo Omleto Giannini, “Woman with Flower.” Source: Wood Turtle “Menstruation in Islam

We can never take this for granted.  

As a first step, I would like to clear the air regarding seven fallacies about menstruation and culture.

1. Menstrual Untouchability Allows Women to Rest

The idea of monthly “rest” has gained much currency in the defense of menstrual untouchability.  To defend this practice on the grounds that it gives a woman rest presumes that women’s labour is available by default and that she cannot decide on her own when to rest.  Must a woman accept that her body is polluting in order to take rest?  Women deserve rest and dignity.

 

2. Menstrual taboo connects us to wisdom from ancient times when women were worshipped.

If indeed women were worshipped then why should they not worship while menstruating?  The argument that women’s chanting must be suppressed lest its energy overpower the mens’ holds water only if you believe that the right of the men to chant must not be infringed, while the women’s right is subordinate.   To suggest that a return to traditional customs such as menstrual taboo will help us create a society that sees fewer crimes against women overlooks the fact that menstrual untouchability is itself a crime against women, just as untouchability itself is a crime against humanity.

3. Menstrual Taboo was necessary in hunter-gatherer societies.

We don’t know how prevalent menstrual taboo was / is in hunter-gatherer societies, but not all hunter-gatherer societies practice it.  Neither in primitive nor in modern societies is menstrual segregation necessary for our species.

 

4. Science will eradicate superstition and empower women.

Yes, science will help us reject false claims, particularly oppressive ones.  But science needs women as much as women need science.  We need to uncover prejudices and challenge stereotypes in the way science is researched and presented and in the way women, men and our bodies are depicted, literally and metaphorically.  For example, reading medical textbooks, Emily Martin shows that descriptions of women’s bodies reflect the values of industrial capitalism as well as gender bias and stereotype.  Take away these values and women’s bodies aren’t treated as factories, nor menstruation as failed production.  Assume women’s autonomy, and the body is described quite differently, as Martin explains.  Medical texts that reinforce stereotypes about men, women and society impact the way doctors and health officials work.

 

5. Menstruation is Painful.

For some women, menstruation is painful.  Unless you have accepted that you are impure or that this is the only way you can get some rest, menstrual untouchability is also painful.  Even if you have accepted it, living with shame about one’s body is painful.  Having your period in a world whose time and space is organized as if menstruation doesn’t exist can also be painful.   For many women, improved nutrition and hygiene, access to rest when they wish, and general freedom and confidence in their own body help to alleviate or eliminate the pain.  So do acupressure, massage and for some, keeping active – difficult to do while segregated.   Often women who are segregated during menses have limited access to the water source, cannot bathe or even change their clothes and menstrual pads as often as they would like, nor can they get a place in the sun to dry cloth pads.   Even women who are not segregated may lack resources required for good menstrual hygiene.  Frequent changing of pads goes a long way in alleviating discomfort, as does the menstrual cup.

 

Fun fact: Ute Pippig finished first in the 1996 Boston Marathon, running 26.2 miles in under 2½ hours, during her period!

 

6. The touch of a menstruating woman is so “hot” or “energetic” that it will spoil the pickle.

Obviously this is not true. Food spoils due to growth of bacteria, mold, etc.   Anyone who has ever charted her temperature knows that our body temperature rises at the time of ovulation and falls just before menstruation.  In any case this temperature change is less than 1 degree centigrade so it doesn’t significantly alter the growth of bacteria.

 

What people mean when they say that the food will spoil is that it will be rendered “maila” or ritually “impure.”  

 

Spoiled for whom?

 

If you adhere to the notion of ritual purity and pollution, and if you believe that menstruation renders a woman untouchable, then ANY food, not only pickle will be unfit for consumption by a non-untouchable, particularly a threaded Brahmin male, once it has been touched by an untouchable.  It remains fit for consumption by other menstruating women.  Another woman may also consume it, but it will render her untouchable.  To regain entry into the house she will have to wash herself and clothes, just as a menstruating woman does at the end of the stipulated period of untouchability.  If a Brahmin male were to touch this contaminated food, he would not only have to wash himself and his clothes but also change his caste-thread in a prescribed ceremony, as mere washing would not remove the ritual contamination.

 

Why pickle?  The reason that pickle is particularly mentioned is that pickle is a food that is preserved such that it doesn’t normally spoil at room temperature.  In some households, it is kept in ritually “pure” conditions at all times so that if a guest, such as a threaded Brahmin male, should arrive who is accustomed only to eat food that is ritually pure, then at least the pickle is available, until other food can be prepared according to specifications.   Were an untouchable to touch this pickle, the guest would be left hungry (though the untouchable would be able to eat it).

 

(Based on my experience living with my elder relations who practiced untouchability, including menstrual untouchability.)

 

7. Rejecting Menstrual Taboo Hurts Religious Sentiments

 

Whose religious sentiments?  Do the religious sentiments of the menstruating woman count?  

 

I cannot speak for other religions but as far as Hinduism goes, its sentiments are most hurt when you fail to question.  Hinduism, if it is anything (which is arguable), is a complex set of often contradictory lines of thought and practice that have been fueled over the generations by relentless interrogation and engagement with ideas and their opposites.  Hindu thought grows not through those who adhere to it dogmatically but through those who rigorously question and test it.  Consider Chokha Mela, who questioned untouchability and the concepts of purity and pollution that underlie it.  Including menstrual untouchability.  Once prohibited from the temple, he is now called Sant Chokha Mela.

And now if you’ll excuse me, I need to go and dance by moon light. My sisters are calling.

dance_041506

Read also:

Rose George, “The Taboo of Menstruation.”

Agnes A. Estioko-Griffin, The Compatibility of Hunting and Mothering among the Agta

R. L. Kelly, Hunting and Menstrual Taboo.

Emily Martin, Medical Metaphors of Women’s Bodies: Menstruation and Menopause.

Jug Suraiya, Hindutva is anti-Hinduism.

Eleanor Zelliot:  Chokhamela and Eknath: Two Bhakti Modes of Legitimacy for Modern Change.

 

Advertisements
  1. Going back to menstrual taboos to allow a woman to rest is not something I need as a woman today. I do not think that menstrual taboos will make women respected more or reduce crime in any manner.

    I read a novel Parva , which is about the Mahabharata, shortly after D’s birth, while I used to spend hours either nursing or pumping. This book describes how the entire royal family laments when a young princess gets her period month after month, because it is one period/egg wasted and will not go on to become a child. I found this very idea oppressive. Where was women’s reproductive freedom even in ancient times, when they were supposed to be respected as goddesses? Even to this day, when a young couple do not have a child after the designated year of marriage, people are “talking” about what could be wrong (with the woman).

    I so totally resonate and relate with what Aravinda writes about menstrual pain in her article. I do not often find my period physically painful and can just usually carry on with whatever I am doing. But it is painful to watch someone else go through the motions of being untouchable. Is it true feminism to be considerate of others beliefs and years of conditioning, just because they are ok with it? Of course I do talk to the women and tell them my views.

    Before I read the article circulated on Facebook, I never had heard about the pickle spoiling taboo. Its seriously ridiculous!

    Thanks Aravinda for this much need article.I enjoyed reading it. I cannot wait for times to change!

    Like

    • Chetana, we don’t wait for times to change, we change the times. I have heard of women who took firm stands against menstrual untouchability and stood their ground in their in-laws homes. The change I would like to see is that menstrual untouchability be recognized as a crime, just as untouchability is, and no one feels it is okay to say “menstruating women not allowed.” Sometimes when I invite people for Sankranti, etc, some people have come to the door to drop off their kids but whispered to me that they are having their periods. I say in a normal voice, “Great! Come on in!” I think from now on I will add, “I do not practice untouchability.”

      Like

  2. Reblogged this on Signals in the Fog and commented:
    Never have I so acutely felt the weight of Jonathan Swift’s remark, “Falsehood flies, and the truth comes limping after it” as now, after responding to a “viral” article propagating pseudo-scientific mumbo-jumbo in connection with menstrual untouchability, which is a crime against women just as untouchability is a crime against humanity.

    To top it off,it suggests, in conclusion, that reviving traditional customs may effect social change and greater respect for women.

    The author is not some cranky old chauvinist male but a woman who works with government schools and health departments to teach girls and women about menstruation,

    Girls certainly do need spaces where they can speak freely and ask questions about menstruation, to know it is not shameful and that their bodies are just fine.

    How awesome would it be if after a presentation on the subject they could go home and declare, “I am not polluting, I don’t have to sit in the corner or in the shed. I can go where I want, when I want. I am free!

    Instead we hear that when girls ask questions about why they are not allowed to touch people, pickers, temples, etc, this particular teacher tells them that untouchability is “a personal choice” and that the myths and rituals reinforcing it are rooted in “ancient wisdom.”

    How many adolescent girls, hearing a teacher offer you on the one hand “ancient wisdom” and on the other “personal choice” will choose the latter?

    I hope this response can increase that number:

    Like

  3. I have come across another ridiculous practice of not touching, watering so called HOLY plants. Its shocking when I hear it over and over again from “educated” lot.

    Like

    • Yes, indeed that is ridiculous. They say that once you tell a lie you have to tell a thousand lies to stay consistent … once you say that that someone is untouchable, where does it end? What about the earth? Should I suspend myself in mid-air so that I am not touching you or the water or those holy plants via the earth? What about the air?

      To ask these questions doesn’t require education, only self-respect and common sense.

      Like

  4. […] can never take this for granted.   As a start, I wrote, “Seven Fallacies about Menstruation and Culture.” Let me also share a video on The Beauty of Red, courtesy of […]

    Like

  5. […] about our experiences with it.  See also Greeting Aunt Flo and Menstrual Cup now in India. And Seven Fallacies about Menstruation and Culture. In between sessions and during the break-out sessions when the main hall was free various groups […]

    Like

  6. […] Seven Fallacies About Menstruation and Culture Menstrupedia: Friendly guide to healthy periods Re: Cycling  Society for Menstruation Cycle Research Museum of Menstruation and Women’s Health […]

    Like

  7. […] Pads: The Medium and the Message Seven Fallacies about Menstruation and Culture Earth and Moon: Period of Change Menstrual Cup Now in India The Worst Thing about the Menstrual […]

    Like

  8. […] including fair-trade and zero-waste initiatives, anti-dowry pledge, period of change campaign against menstrual untouchability and other practices of untouchability and caste.  I shared examples from a classroom discussion […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: